My friend and I are trying to decide where we should have pizza, and I say Mario’s, but he says Millie’s. Can you help us? Let’s look at the features of each place.
Millie’s Old Mill
Millie’s Old Mill has plenty of appetizers, including Homemade Mozzarella, Antipasto, and Meatballs in Marinara sauce. The Homemade Mozzarella is made with fresh basil and olive oil. It is a quick but amazing appetizer. The antipasto is a mix of black olives, grape tomatoes, and red onions, tossed in a sauce, with meats and cheeses on the side. Meatballs in marinara sauce are another favorite and are topped with some fresh basil. These are just the three best appetizers, according to the reviews.
Millie’s has a lot of entree options that consist of pizza, soup, and sides. There are also sandwiches and platters. Millie’s is best known for their pizzas and has a wide variety of pies. You can have your choice of toppings as well. There are even two types of pizzas, each with its own unique taste: Coal-fired and Wood-fired.
The pricing is reasonable. Pizzas are standard, about $25 per pizza. Sandwiches are around $20, and entrees start at $18.
Millie’s has mostly 5-star reviews, and it’s important to note that the ones that are three stars and below are very old. Some people say it’s the best, some say it’s good. But all in all, Millie’s is one of the best pizza restaurants in the area.
Mario’s Brick Oven
Some appetizers are garlic bread and chicken wings (served with blue cheese). In addition, there’s bruschetta made with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, red onions, basil, and special herbs. They also have salads like Caesar salad and tossed salad made with mixed greens, carrots, and cherry tomatoes. Plus, they have wraps such as a chicken buffalo wrap made with lettuce, tomatoes, and bleu cheese, and an Italian combo wrap with ham, salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes. The most popular dishes are their garlic knots, pepperoni pizza, fettuccine alfredo, gyros, and fried calamari.
Mario’s has many selections for appetizers and entrées, like a pizza for $10-$20, subs for $8.50-$11.00, and pasta for $19.00. Then there are deals like buy one, get one at 50%. Mario’s is located at 196 Speedwell Ave and is rated at 4.3 stars. The general cost is $10-$20 per person, and vegetarian options are available.
Now that you know the pizza places, can you help us? There are many more, but these 2 are the best from the 2 of us. Please, guys, we need this!
Works Cited
Bjorg, Gudny, et al. “No-Rise Pizza Dough Recipe.” Allrecipes, 4 February 2025, https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/6776/pizza-dough-i/. Accessed 21 January 2026.
https://yelp.com/milliesoldmill.
